Wednesday, November 26, 2008

A false sense of abundance

If there is one thing we are good at here in the U.S. it is making ourselves feel like we have more than we really do. Some of it comes from a strong sense of national pride. This is the United States, since WW II we have been on top of the world, an economic powerhouse of growth and prosperity. Now we are possibly heading into a prolonged recession or a maybe a depression. Where we are in technical terms is less important than the mentality that is out there which is that this is the worst its been in 70 years. While on the one hand there is a lot of gloom in the economic forecast I struggle to feel that this can really be compared to 70 years ago. I was raised with stories from my grandparents about what it was like growing up around that time. The Great Depression created a perception of scarcity and conservation that we do not have today. As I was listening to MPR yesterday I heard someone commenting on one of the shows about the bailout package and how the government had given Citibank all this money and yet now they were dramatically raising their interest rates on credit cards. Their comment was that by raising the rates we were punishing the people who likely needed the money the most. Now I am opposed to predatory lending practices, in particular business that will do the loan until your next paycheck. I find their rates and practices to be exploitive. That being said I also think we need to find a way to make an adjustment here in the U.S. I think we make it too easy for people to simply accrue more debt. We as a culture do not think about what we can afford now, we think about what we can afford later. We also have a higher expectation of what we need to survive. Now, there are a number of people who are in very great need and I do not mean to lessen that. At the same time I see so many people with cell phones and other accessories that are struggling to stay ahead. We create this perception that we need all these things and in doing so only increase the amount we have to spend just to stay afloat. I like having a cell phone and as a pastor I could potentially argue I need it for my job, but I do not think I should hav a cell phone if I am struggling to pay the mortgage. A cell phone is not worth going into debt over, neither is my cable television, my high speed Internet, or many other luxuries I enjoy. This Thanksgiving I think we need to look at our abundance and be truly thankful for what we have but we also need to look at what we have an question whether we should really have it all. Is this perception of abundance worth the debt that we as a society are accruing to have it? I think if we stopped seeing credit cards as a solution we might have a better sense of our current abundance or lack thereof.

1 comment:

Sam Pepi said...

"Now I am opposed to predatory lending practices, in particular business that will do the loan until your next paycheck. I find their rates and practices to be exploitive." - “Defining and Detecting Predatory Lending,” a study by Donald P. Morgan, Research Officer, Federal Reserve Bank of New York, concludes that payday loans do not fit the definition of predatory because they are not a “welfare reducing” form of credit. To the contrary, the author suggests that payday lenders enhance the welfare of households by increasing the supply of credit.

I'm wondering why you are so opposed to short-term credit options? Especially when they are offered by reputable lending stores, particularly those who are CFSA members. Payday lending plays a necessary role, providing hard-working people with a reasonable, well-regulated option for meeting unexpected or unbudgeted expenses and other short-term financial needs.

With regard to your comment about the rates, well, there is nothing exploitative about them. Payday advances are two week, not annual loans. For each $100 advanced, customers pay a typical fee of $15-$17. Because payday loans are two-week loans they cannot be offered at the same annual rates as annual credit products such as credit cards, auto loans and home mortgages.

If you consider the fees for other products, you will see that payday lenders provide a desirable alternative.

$100 payday advance = $15; overdraft protection = $29; late fee on credit card bill = $37; $100 off-shore internet payday loan= $25; bounced check and NSF/Merchant fee= $56.* *Source: http://www.cfsa.net/cost_comparison.html (https://www.bankrate.com/brm/news/chk/chkstudy/20081027-banking-habits-a1.asp )

Yes, there are many people who live beyond their means, so maybe that's where the cycle of debt is coming from. Payday lenders don't exist to babysit these citizens, they need to take responsibility for their own actions and financial decisions, especially when the reputable lending stores provide their consumers with all of the information and options regarding the product per CFSA's Best Practices.